Friendshas been widely regarded as one of the most iconic sitcoms, even decades following its conclusion — and for good reason. The series was successful for many reasons, with the chemistry among its six leads being the most important. Arguably the most talked about relationship on the series belongs to Ross Geller and Rachel Green, played byDavid SchwimmerandJennifer Aniston, who both recently reunited for a Super Bowl commercial. Both actors are now household names, and Rachel Green is often cited as Aniston’s breakout role. Because she is such a prominent member of the cast, it’s hard to imagineFriendswithout her. However, according to film and cinema studies professorSaul Austerlitz’s 2019 bookGeneration Friends, the show had a close call during Season 1: they almost lost Jennifer Aniston halfway through.
Ross Geller, Rachel Green, Monica Geller, Joey Tribbiani, Chandler Bing, and Phoebe Buffay are six twenty-somethings living in New York City. Over 10 years and seasons, these friends go through life lessons, family, love, drama, friendship, and comedy.
Jennifer Aniston Was Stuck Between ‘Friends’ and ‘Muddling Through’
1994 was a busy year for Jennifer Aniston. She ended up acting for several different pilots in the hopes that something would last. After shootingfive other TV pilots, she found her sitcom family with NBC’sFriendsas Rachel Green, but not before shooting six episodes of a completely different series. At the time, CBS was giving a chance to a new sitcom calledMuddling Through, and Aniston had a prominent role as the protagonist’s daughter Madeline. The show was promised six episodes, and if the ratings were on their side, they could potentially land a full season. However, Aniston ended up being one of the top picks forFriendsas well, meaning she was stuck between the two shows.
IfMuddling Throughmanaged to… well, muddle through and get its first season greenlit, thenAniston wouldn’t be able to participate in the filming ofFriendsafter the first half of the season. Rachel Green would either have to be written out of the show or replaced with a different actress, neither of which were ideal options. Aniston was theFriendsshowrunners’top pick for the role of Rachel Green, so her ties toMuddling Throughput them in a tough spot. Scheduling-wise,Muddling Throughhad to secure a good date and time to airso that people would actually tune in for the show.
This ‘Friends’ Moment Is Why Rachel Shouldn’t Have Gotten Off the Plane
Heaven help the fool who eats that damn sandwich.
Well,Muddling Throughaired its first episode… in the summer, on a Saturday night. With a date and time when so few people would be tuning in,Muddling Throughwas disadvantaged from the start. Nonetheless, they could still hurt NBC’s up-and-coming hit by depriving them of one of their lead actors. If the show became any more popular, Aniston would have to back out ofFriendsin order to continue withMuddling Through. The uncertainty got to a point whereAniston had to sit out some ofFriends' early photoshoots. If it turned out she wouldn’t be able to continue on the show,Friendsneeded to have official images that didn’t include her.
What Is ‘Muddling Through’ About?
Muddling Through, created by producerBarton Dean, follows the story of Connie Drego (Stephanie Hodge), an ex-convict who’s trying to get her life back on track. She spends a few years in prison after attacking her ex-husband Sonny (D. David Morin) and now works at her family’s motel and diner in an attempt to build a better life for herself. Connie isn’t alone in her plight, though, because she has two daughters.Aimee Brooksplays Kerri and Aniston plays Madeline (Aniston) who is now married to Duane (Scott Waara), the cop who arrested Connie. The show also had a gallery of supporting and recurring cast members ready to go on the chance that it was picked up for a full season.
‘Friends’ Showrunners Needed To Win Over Jennifer Aniston
Stuck with their competition, theFriendsshowrunners came up with a strategy to ensure thatMuddling Throughnever got their Season 1. There wasn’t anything they could do to influence CBS’s decisions, but, thanks to strategistPreston Beckman, there was a way to tip the scale in their favor. What ifMuddling Through’s already-undesirable time slot had steep competition? Beckman’s plan was simple but effective. WhenMuddling Throughwas airing that summer,NBC started airing a line of TV movies, all of which wereDanielle Steeladaptations. As a prominent romance author and a #1New York Timesbestseller, Steel already had a large following of fans, ensuring a substantial female viewer base for the time slot — all of whom would now be tuning in to NBC on summer Saturdays. Which would be more enticing, after all? A little-known brand-new TV series airing on a Saturday night in the summer months, or a line of films with familiar stories adapted from a respected and established author’s work?
Muddling Throughdidn’t stand much of a chance, premiering in July 1994 and only continuing through to its tenth episode later that September. (Episode 11 was left unaired when the show was canceled.)Muddling Throughbarely lasted three months, andFriendsaired for 10 seasonsand as many years, with reruns still playing as we speak.Muddling Throughmay have gotten their first pick with Jennifer Aniston, butFriendscertainly had the last laugh.Thanks to the strategic thinking of Beckman and the lineup of Danielle Steel adaptations(of all things),Friendswas able to keep the iconic character of Rachel Green without recasting. They didn’t need to bother taking photos without Aniston — she stayed for all ten seasons and became part of one of the mosticonic couples in TVhistory. It was a close call, and it took the sacrifice of another show, butFriendsended up being Aniston’s breakout role, launching her career and investing millions of viewers in the lives of six friends in New York just trying to figure themselves out.
Friendsis available to watch on Max in the U.S.
Watch on Max
